Results of the 11th Annual (2007) Survey

Responses are indicative of desire for higher end plastic models, not brass. Sound option desirable on all locomotives. DCC option or "friendly" assumed.

Some early and late subclasses are combined on one line. If a manufacturer can produce the basic matching mechanism, then appropriate eras and subclasses should be derivable from that.

Understand that some responses were so general that they were included on a separate line even though they could be interpreted to be a more specific class already showing in the results.

It is VERY important to stress that this survey counts "types" of models desired and not "quantities" desired. For any given type, typically many quantities are desired. For instance, well over 100 HO scale H8/9/10 series locomotives are desired by the respondents.

-----------------------HO SCALE-----------------------------------
STEAM LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(31) H8 / H9 / H10 series
(20) L1s  (Life Like / Walthers project rumored dead)
(5) B6
(5) N2sa
(5) Q2
(4) S2
(3) E6
(3) G5
(2) H6sb
(2) K4 Streamlined (3768)
(2) N1
(2) M1 (not a/b)
(1) D16b
(1) D16sb
(1) I1s (Votes likely subdued due to PCM announced model)
(1) Q1
(1) S1
(1) T1 with prototype "Buick" nose
(1) T1 original production version with portholes
(1) T1 (uh, BLI?)

ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(If desiring MP-series variants, please put under passenger equipment
as the PRR carried these on the passenger roster.)
(21) P5/P5a/P5a Modified series
(8) E44
(5) B1 "Rat"
(2) DD-1
(2) GG-1 with high air intakes
(2) O1c
(1) Any of the early 1950s trial units
(1) DD-2
(1) E2 
(1) GG-1 w/flat pilot
(1) GG-1 #4800 "Old Rivets"

DIESEL LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(16) BP20 Baldwin DR 6-4-2000 Passenger Shark
(16) BH50/BP60 Baldwin DR 12-8-3000 Centipede
(6) BS24m Baldwin RT624 centercab
(5) BF16 Baldwin RF16 Shark
(3) LS25 Lima transfer unit
(2) BF15 Baldwin DR 4-4-1500 Shark
(2) ES6 EMD SW1
(1) AF24 Alco RS27
(1) FS12m FM H-12-44
(1) AS16ms Alco RS-3 with steam generator
(1) BS10as Baldwin DR 4-4-1000
(1) BS12 / BS12as / BS12m Baldwin S-12
(1) BS6 Baldwin DS 4-4-600
(1) BS7 / BS7m Baldwin 
(1) ES15m GP9 Phase I
(1) GF25a GE U25c
(1) FS20 FM H20-44
(1) EMD E7 Phase II
(1) FS10 FM H 10-44
(1) GS4 GE 44-tonner

FREIGHT ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(6) H25 / H25a
(5) G31 / G31a gon
(4) K8 stock
(4) X29b box
(3) GLC / GLCA
(2) F39 flat
(2) X29d box 
(2) X40b / "Merchandise Service" box
(2) G41 coil cars
(1) G22 gon
(1) Depressed flat (that leaves speculation open!)
(1) X29 ($15 range)
(1) X29 dreadnaught re-release Red Caboose
(1) H30 cov hopper
(1) H32 cov hpper
(1) H36 / H37
(1) G27 gon
(1) G29 gon
(1) FM flat
(1) F31 flat
(1) X31 box
(1) G35 gon
(1) Any FGE reefers from 40s-50s (try InterMountain!)
(1) X59 box
(1) GS gon Bowser with brake staff and platform relocated
(1) K9 stock
(1) F30d w/TrucTrain trailer
(1) H21a (Kadee quality)
(1) Tank car (TM8 ?)
(1) X23 box
(1) G43 gon
(1) H35 hopper
(1) F22 flat
(1) R7 reefer

PASSENGER ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(8) P70 series (orig, r, far, fbr)
(6) MP54 series
(5) P70 rebuilds (kr, gsr)
(4) D85C / D85D twin unit diner
(4) POS211
(3) POS21
(3) BM70m
(3) PS6L / any mid-train lounge/bar
(3) PRR gas electric car, Doodlebug 250/350, Brill
(3) Broadway Limited consist (post-war rumored from Walthers)
(2) PS21
(2) PS106 (plan 4129)
(2) Congressional Limited consist
(2) Heavyweight 6SEC-6DBR (pan 4084 semi-streamlined)
(1) PB70
(1) MP85
(1) D70
(1) heavyweight diner, any class 30s-50s
(1) B60 (clerestory roof) (Bethlehem Car Works)
(1) BM70k
(1) BM70n
(1) D78 modernized
(1) PS105
(1) X42 mail storage box
(1) PS18
(1) PS124 (pan 4130)
(1) B70
(1) Broadway Limited "FoM" consist (rumored from PCM)
(1) Pennsylvania Limited Yellow Kid consist
(1) Congo coach
(1) Congo twin unit diner
(1) Congo observation
(1) Budd non-corrugated Senator & Congo cars
(1) Heavyweight 8SEC-Buffet (plan 3989A)
(1) Cafe-Coach

NON-REVENUE ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(4) 150-ton wreck derrick
(3) double track Russell snow plow
(2) GP / GPa ballast hopper
(2) H21L ballast hopper
(2) Z74 business car
(2) tower car (based on FM flat)
(1) 250-ton crane
(1) derrick
(1) Ballast cleaning cars
(1) PRR-correct Jordan spreader
(1) Y4/Y6
(1) wheel car
(1) Scale test car
(1) work train (Westerfield Camp Cars?)
(1) N5b
(1) N6 center cupola cabin (announced by Walthers)
(1) NC cabin
(1) ND cabin
(1) TM8 tank (F&C?)
(1) N5 / N5b without crash bars
(1) Walthers N6 in solid freight car color and Pennsylvania with bar lettering
(1) heavyweight passenger cars in MoW livery
(1) F30 flats with rail racks
(1) 90F82 tender

STRUCTURES DESIRED:
(3) PRR Roundhouse (Renovo, Northumberland)
(3) Lines West tower
(3) Signal bridges
(2) freight house
(1) West Slope towers (NY, SO, C, SG, SQ)
(1) PRR style yard light towers
(1) PRR standard wood water tower
(1) CORK tower
(1) VIEW tower (under development - Merchandise Service)
(1) Pump, boilerhouse (Hawstone track pans)
(1) ZOO tower
(1) MEADOWBROOK tower
(1) Lewistown station
(1) Altoona station
(1) Coaling towers
(1) Single-arch rough-cut stone bridge
(1) Two-track steel viaduct
(1) Lines West station
(1) South Amboy engine house
(1) Harrisburg train shed
(1) Washington Union Station umbrella shed
(1) Block station structure (KS, Max, GB, Hubbard)
(1) Wood 2-story interlock tower, e.g. Worthington, OH
(1) Mt. Union, PA passenger station (pre-grade crossing elimination project 	
		relocation)
(1) Mt. Union, PA freight office
(1) any of the italianate architecture combination depots of the C.V.R.R. 
		(Newville, Shippensburg, Chambersburg)
(1) Q tower
(1) switch tower

OTHER DESIRED:
(6) Dwarf signals
(3) Scale-size signal heads
(3) Catenary components
(1) Pre-1950's company service vehicles
(1) Pennsy-style oil-tender conversion kit
(1) 2s/K2sa/K3s conversion boiler and trailing truck for Bowser K4 drive
(1)  E3sd conversion boiler and trailing truck for Bowser E6 mechanism
(1) 110P97a tender
(1) 70F70 tender
(1) Pipe fence
(1) Roller bearing 2DP5 passenger trucks
(1) Fleet of Modernism decals (Society is working on)
(1) single shoe pantographs for MP54's
(1) Resin replicas of engine number keystones and builders plates
(1) Conversion kit for Walthers tugboat
(1) barge
(1) Decals for decals, including LCL service, etc

-----------------------N SCALE-----------------------------------
STEAM LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(11) H8s / H9s / H10s series
(8) I1s w/various tenders, front ends
(6) K4s w/various front ends
(4) M1a / M1b (PCM project is likely stillborn)
		(Votes likely subdued due to PCM announced model)
(3) E6s
(2) M1 (not a/b)
(1) H6sb
(1) D16sb
(1) N2sa
(1) L1s
(1) B6sb

ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(If desiring MP-series variants, please put under passenger equipment
as the PRR carried these on the passenger roster.)
(9) P5 / P5a / P5a modified series
(5) E44
(5) B1 "Rat"
(2) GG-1 (announced by Kato)
(1) DD-1
(1) FF-2

DIESEL LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(6) BP20 Baldwin DR 6-4-2000 passenger shark
(5) BS24m Baldwin RT-624 centercab (project rumored in forums)
(2) BP60 / BH50 Baldwin DR 12-8-3000 centipede
(2) GS4 / GS4m GE 44-tonner
(2) GF25a GE U25c
(1) ES6 EMD SW1
(1) A6
(1) EF36 EMD SD45
(1) AF24 Alco RS27
(1) EFS17m EMD GP9b
(1) LS25 Lima T2500 transfer unit
(1) BS7 Baldwin DS 4-4-750
(1) ES15m EMD GP7
(1) BRS16m Baldwin RS-12
(1) BRS16m Baldwin AS-16
(1) BF15 Baldwin DR 4-4-1500 Shark
(1) AF36 Alco C636
(1) FM20 ???

FREIGHT ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(4) XL box
(2) H25 hopper
(2) X23 box
(2) R7 reefer
(2) K9 stock
(2) H30 cov hopper
(1) K7a stock
(1) GS gon
(1) KF stock
(1) X28 box
(1) X25 box
(1) G38 / G39
(1) GRa gon
(1) GS gon
(1) X31a (injection molded) (resin available)
(1) H ???

PASSENGER ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(8) MP54 series
(4) R50b reefer
(3) P70 series (P70FBR in development by Wheels Of Time, status unknown)
(2) BM70m
(2) D85C / D85D twin unit diner
(1) BM70
(1) D78 diner
(1) BM62T mail/baggage trailer
(1) Congressional Limited consist
(1) Broadway Limited "FoM" consist
(1) any Budd stainless cars
(1) Lightweight observation cars (too general)
(1) Pullman fleet cars (perhaps too general)
(1) B60 (injection molded)

NON-REVENUE ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(4) N8 cabin
(4) N6b cabin
(3) ND cabin
(2) Camp cars (XL's)
(2) Z74d business car
(1) N5b cabin
(1) N6
(1) 210F75 tender
(1) NX23 cabin
(1) Motor car with trailer
(1) Ballast groomer
(1) tower car (FM flat based)

STRUCTURES DESIRED:
(3) VIEW tower (under development - Merchandise Service)
(3) BANKS tower (under development - Merchandise Service)
(2) ROCKVILLE tower (announced by Merchandise Service)
(1) JACKS tower
(1) CORK tower
(1) ZOO tower
(1) Harrisburg station (no, it's not Jerry!)
(1) Lancaster station and platforms
(1) Altoona passenger station
(1) PRR roundhouse
(1) PRR standard water tower
(1) small framed station
(1) small 3-sided station shelter

OTHER DESIRED:
(2) catenary components
(1) PRR-type locomotive water cranes
(1) PRR cast rail-hiway crossing signs
(1) Conversion firebox to make ConCor's N2s into an N2sa
(1) Pennsy style pantographs
(1) shells/conversion kits (like the old GHQ Mikado
		kits) for H, G, L, K and D-class steam locomotives
(1) Pot signals
(1) 60's fuel rack details
(1) PRR company vehicles (two announced from Classic Metal Works)
(1) shells and conversion kits
(1) PRR lineside details (Alkem Scale Models)
(1) single shoe pantographs for MP54's
(1) PRR style mileposts

------------------------G SCALE-----------------------------------
STEAM LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(1) L1
(1) H9

ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(If desiring MP-series variants, please put under passenger equipment
as the PRR carried these on the passenger roster.)

DIESEL LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:

FREIGHT ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(1) 2-bay coal hopper

PASSENGER ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:

NON-REVENUE ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:

STRUCTURES DESIRED:
(1) towers
(1) passenger sheds, stations
(1) coaling towers

OTHER DESIRED:

------------------------S SCALE-----------------------------------
STEAM LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:

ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(If desiring MP-series variants, please put under passenger equipment
as the PRR carried these on the passenger roster.)

DIESEL LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(1) EP20 EMD E7

FREIGHT ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(1) GLa gon
(1) X29 box
(1) G22 gon

PASSENGER ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(1) P70 series

NON-REVENUE ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:

STRUCTURES DESIRED:

OTHER DESIRED:


------------------------O SCALE-----------------------------------
STEAM LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(1) G5
(1) L1
(1) K2

ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:
(If desiring MP-series variants, please put under passenger equipment
as the PRR carried these on the passenger roster.)

DIESEL LOCOMOTIVES DESIRED:

FREIGHT ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(1) XL box
(1) GL / GLC hopper
(1) GRa gon

PASSENGER ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:
(1) 30' RPO (BM70k?)

NON-REVENUE ROLLING STOCK DESIRED:

STRUCTURES DESIRED:

OTHER DESIRED:
(1) 75' standard turntable
(1) Whistle and mile marker signs
(1) Plate girder bridge girders